| 2023 | Nic Altobelli | Andrew | St. Xavier University |
| 2023 | Eddie Artajo III | Schaumburg Christian School | Olivet Nazarene |
| 2023 | Noah Caceres | Reavis | University of Illinois - Springfield |
| 2023 | Cole Cacini | Prospect | Carroll University |
| 2023 | Jeremy Florez | Taft | Joliet Junior College |
| 2023 | Francis Heinzmann | Oak Park River Forest | Joliet Junior College |
| 2023 | Dominic Jacoby | Taft | Spoon River College |
| 2023 | Aris Kosiek | Montini | Missouri Southern State University |
| 2023 | Connor Lasch | Loyola Academy | Concorida University - Wisconsin |
| 2023 | Nathan Montalto | Reavis | St. Xavier University |
| 2023 | Jake Nawrocki | Hampshire | North Park University |
| 2023 | Calvin Proskey | Oak Park River Forest | University of California - Santa Barbara |
| 2023 | Dean Rokkas | Fremd | Pima Community College |
| 2023 | Michael Southard | Loyola Academy | Concorida University - Wisconsin |
| 2023 | Jack Rozmus | York | Ashland University |
| 2023 | Troy Stukenberg | Lyons Township | St. Xavier University |
| 2023 | Jason Valdez | Glenbard West | Concorida University - Wisconsin |
| 2023 | Sam Viniard | Lyons Township | Univeristy Wisconsin - Lacrosse |
